Schedule Your Free Consultation
Toll-free: 866-456-6423
Local: 916-677-4979
Rosenthal & Kreeger LLP
  • More Than 25 Years Experience
  • Excellence
  • Compassion
  • Integrity
Practice Areas

How much is emotional pain worth?

A gynecologist has been secretly taking explicit photographs and videos of his patients without their knowledge or consent. How much is their emotional pain worth?

This question is at the heart of a case surrounding a Johns Hopkins gynecologist named Nikita Levy, who had taken thousands of videos and images of his patients since beginning to practice in 1988. In February 2013, authorities brought forward charges against Mr. Levy, who committed suicide days later. 

Mr. Levy's patients, many of whom are poor and African-American, then filed a class-action lawsuit, according to The Washington Post, and settled for $190 million in July of 2014. Though settled, the lawsuit has probed some to examine the deep, lasting effects of psychological and emotional trauma, and how that could play out in personal injury lawsuits. 

Specifically, 8,344 of Mr. Levy's patients brought the suit forward, after attesting to experiencing trauma, psychological torment and lost sleep. 

Since Mr. Levy's actions left no visible or tangible scars, and his victims were unaware of his actions until they became public, the question of the extent of injury is seen as subjective by some. 

As such, based on assessments, each woman named in the class action lawsuit is set to receive between $1,750 and $26,048, with $32 million of the settlement reserved for attorney fees.

Assessing psychological trauma 

According to Kenneth Feinberg, an attorney tasked with delegating settlements to victims of mass tragedies, psychological trauma is often a tricky territory for lawyers to explore, so much so that many even avoid taking cases of this nature, and prefer to focus on cases with physical injuries. 

To determine damage in this lawsuit, a panel of doctors created a list of questions that attempted to capture the breadth of the women's experiences. The women were then divided into four groups, each one entitled to a different level of the settlement money.

However, it's ultimately difficult to determine the extent of psychological trauma, as well as fair and just compensation. 

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Success Stories
  • Avvo Clients Choice
  • Avvo Rating 10.0 Superb Top Attorneys
  • Million Dollar Advocates Forum
  • Peer Review Rated
  • American Association for Justice
  • Consumer Attorneys California

EnvelopFind Out How we can help you

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

2251 Douglas Blvd., Suite 120
Roseville, CA 95661

Toll Free: 866-456-6423
Phone: 916-677-4979
Fax: 916-774-7203
Roseville Law Office Map

1903 21st Street
Sacramento, CA 95811

Toll Free: 866-456-6423
Phone: 916-677-4979
Phone: 916-229-6744
Fax: 916-774-7203
Sacramento Law Office Map